Pathways Deep Dive

1st edition – 2025/2026

Ecological  crises  and  political  tensions: understanding  their  connection  and  exploring  counteractions

Ecological crises and political tensions

The recent rise in authoritarian and far-right movements around the world is increasingly becoming an issue of concern for the scientific community. Many of such movements have been linked to climate skepticism, denial, and hostility toward scientists and environmentalists. In right-wing authoritarian and populist ideology, climate policy and action is often portrayed as a threat to national interests, which benefits a “cosmopolitan elite” at the expense of the people (Olsen 1999, Forchtner and Kolvraa 2015, Voss 2014). Some recent examples include Orban’s politics in Hungary, Bolsonaro in Brazil, Modi in India, Trump in the United States, or Duterte in the Philippines. 

Although evidence shows that scientists still have the trust of the general public, the rising influence of climate obstruction by far-right and authoritarian movements risks distorting public understanding of ecological crises and undermining scientific credibility. Contrary to what might seem, the relationship of authoritarian, far-right movements with ecology is far from straightforward, with many of such movements employing discourses and practices to co-opt, distort, or weaponize ecological issues (Forchtner 2022, Lubarda 2023). This stance can translate into cuts in funding, denigration of scientists, repression of indigenous groups and environmental activists, and threats to the already scarcely supported multilateral process on international climate policy. 

Today, the scientific community faces the critical challenge of addressing the complex links between political tensions and ecological crises which threaten to silence their work and the alarms they have been sounding for decades. As critical science and knowledge thrive in open and democratic societies, understanding the mechanisms of authoritarian and far-right tactics is essential if we are to provide effective answers and counter-strategies to the current anti-science and anti-democratic tendencies.

Scientific Advisors: 
  • Noémi Gonda, Associate Professor at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences.
  • Bruno Locatelli, Environmental scientist in the Forests and Societies research unit at CIRAD, University of Montpellier.

Objectives

With this Deep Dive we aim to: 

  • Raise awareness and understanding of the challenges facing the sustainability science community, as well as the many forms of resistance and responses within and outside science that have taken shape against far-right and authoritarian dynamics;
  • Create a safe space where the scientific community can come together, reflect on and share their understandings, questions and lived experiences, in a spirit of giving room to critical reflections on both the analysis of the situation at stake and how to shape appropriate responses. 
 

While this Deep Dive largely draws from our Western perspective on democracy, authoritarianism, and the role of science in society as a starting point, we recognize that these concepts may take different forms and understandings depending on the context in which they emerge. By including a comparative approach, the Deep Dive will examine different examples of far-right and authoritarian narratives and the impact they have on science and the environment, allowing researchers and scientists in our community to learn more about such connections and the different perspectives that exist on these issues. 

In the coming months, we will be organizing activities and publishing resources to better understand these complex connections and foster critical reflections. 

The key questions that the Deep Dive will touch upon include: 

  • What do we know about the connections between the rise of far-right and authoritarian movements, and the ecological and climate crises? How do they vary depending on different geographical, political and socio-economic contexts? 
  • How do such connections question democracy and the role of scientists in society? 
  • How can scientists working on socio-ecological issues react to these forces that often seek to weaken their voice, credibility and work?

Activities

🎙️ Deep Dive Podcast | Unpacking Environmental Mis- and Disinformation

Disinformation works as a business model. Who is behind it? What makes us vulnerable to believe it? And what strategies do we have to counter it?

Disinformation is a result of an organized, systemic network of actors and is a significantly profitable endeavour – both economically and politically – for those behind the scenes. The success of these networks lies also in their ability to exploit the psychological factors that make us more vulnerable to believe fake news in the first place.

By combining a systemic and psychological perspective on disinformation, this episode helps us paint a better picture of how disinformation actually operates and what strategies we can employ to counter it. 

Speakers: 

🎲 Board Game | And if it was you? Defending science in the face of threats for democracy

This board game, developed and tested by our team for the Open Science day of Sorbonne Université, aims to help young and non-academic audiences better understand the realities and challenges faced by researchers today. The game invites participants to put themselves in the shoes of a sustainability scientist. Players must make difficult choices and respond to challenging situations, directly connecting the dilemmas of a scientific career with the pressures of the current political climate.

Designed as an awareness-raising tool for audiences who are not necessarily familiar with sustainability science or the challenges faced by scientists in authoritarian times, the board game can serve as a tool during workshops, classes or booths in a variety of contexts.

The game is freely available to print and use both in English and French. 

Webinars

🌀 Deep Dive Forum | Reimagining our Practices and Pedagogies: Sustainability Science in Authoritarian Times

This Pathways Deep Dive webinar provided a space to discuss how sustainability research and education can adapt to and transform within complex political landscapes. Viola Hakkarainen explored the tensions that sustainability researchers and educators face when engaging with real-world societal change and present the principles to catalyse the inner–outer transformations needed. Wesley Maraire spoke on the language of transformation and how these agenda are co-opted within academic institutions. Finally, Jonas Torrens  presented a recent initiative called ‘impossible projects’, a new collaboration with the KIN (Dutch Transformative Climate Research programme) to spotlight research often overlooked by traditional funding

Discussion Facilitator:
Bruno Locatelli
, CIRAD, University of Montpellier

🌀 Deep Dive Forum | Far right ecologies: what challenges for sustainability science?

This Deep Dive Forum critically examined the discourses and practices employed by far-right movements to co-opt, distort, or weaponize ecological issues. It also explored the urgent implications of such political dynamics for sustainability research and practice.

Speakers:
Bernhard Forchtner
, Associate Professor, University of Leicester
Balša Lubarda
, MSCA Postdoctoral Fellow, Universitat Pompeu Fabra
Shehnoor Khurram
, PhD candidate, York University, Fulbright Scholar and Visiting Researcher at Georgetown University

Discussion Facilitator:
Noémi Gonda
, Researcher and Associate Professor, Swedish University of Agricultural Science

Questionnaire

Articles

Other Organisations, Projects & Initiatives

There is a wealth of organisations, projects and initiatives that have been working on the connections between political tensions and ecological crises. These are some that we came across in our research and inspired our work.

If you are working on a similar project or initiative, or you have suggestions to add on our list, don’t hesitate to reach out to viola.baldeschi@futureearth.org. 

Emerging Takeaways